Adult-FanFiction.org : Movies

Cruel Love Anthology	By : CarolineSpencer Category: 1 through F > Cruel Intentions Views: 8536 -:- Recommendations : 1 -:- Currently Reading : 0
Disclaimer: I do not own Cruel Intentions or Dangerous Liaisons and make no profit off of this story

Chapter List
- 4
- 5
- 6
Cruel Love Anthology

Disclaimer: Don't own it.

Author's Note: Yeah so this is smutty. I realize this whole series is smutty, but this is especially smutty. Be warned there's a threesome. There's some guy on guy action. There's some DP and drug use. If anything doesn't appeal turn away now or read on for further debauchery.

Chapter Summary: While visiting the Valmont's, Prince Nikolas is determined to live out a long held sexual fantasy involving everyone's favorite Upper East Side debutante. Sebastian offers to arrange it, but things don't quite progress how the prince expected…

E is for Envy

As was typical with a night out with Sebastian, things ended with a bang. An epic bang to be more specific. One I was likely to carry with me for the rest of my life. But I'm getting ahead of myself…

I'll admit I didn't have high hopes for the night when we arrived at the Valmont townhouse that evening. Sebastian and I had been out partying for a better part of the evening. It was my last night in the states and since I had spent a better part of my 'vacation' doing photo-ops with politicians and having diners with foreign dignitaries, this was actually the only opportunity to have any genuine fun. I intended to make the most of it and I succeeded.

I received a blow job from an underage actress at Pure. Dropped some ecstasy at a dive bar on the Lower East Side. Fingered the Sports Illustrated cover model in the bathroom of an upscale hotel. Fuck, I loved American woman. Even if I wasn't a good looking mother fucker (which I was) I still wouldn't have had any trouble getting laid. One hint at my accent and a glimpse of my Rolex and they had their hands down my pants in seconds. It didn't hurt being a famous Royal either.

"Hey, your highness," Sebastian sneered at me from outside the limo, "You planning on crashing in the car tonight or are you going to join me inside?"

"I'm coming dipshit." I guzzled down the rest of my scotch and joined him out on the sidewalk. The chilly New York weather hit my face, but the drugs I took earlier made me numb against it. Looking upward I stared at the towering skyscrapers above me mesmerized. "Fuck me, I love New York."

Valmont chuckled, "You dropped enough E to love everything tonight." He grabbed me by the lapel of my jacket and dragged me forward. "Come along Prince Nicky."

I scowled at the horrid childhood nickname he insisted on dragging out at every opportunity to taunt me and shoved him playfully as we both stumbled inside the townhouse.

I should explain I've known the Valmont family since I was child. My father was good friends with Edward Valmont and I had spent many a summer getting into mischief with Sebastian while our parents were doing god knows what. Valmont was the perfect playmate. Always up for anything and he never minded taking the blame when our parents inevitably found out we were up to no good. Not much has changed.

Whenever I came on these little trips to the States I always stayed with Sebastian, insisting to my father that it was easier and required less security but the old man saw right through me. He knew Valmont and his reputation, and even though he was a few years younger than myself, he thought him a bad influence on me. Still, as Edward was one of his best friends (a man who was hardly a saint himself) he couldn't really object to my staying with them.

"I can't believe you turned down that piece of ass at the club. She was practically panting to bring you home with her," Sebastian exclaimed as we entered into the quiet formal sitting room. He turned on a light and strut over to the bar. Even though he had consumed just at much illegal substances as me he didn't seem any worse for wear. Continuing on with his rant he explained, "She wanted to introduce you to her roommate. You know what that means?"

"She wanted to fuck a prince," I drawled.

"She wanted a threesome. You could be banging two hot chicks right now, but instead you choose to take me home instead. What gives?"

I was only half listening to Sebastian at that point. My attention had drifted to down the hall where I noticed a bedroom light come on. So, she was home…

"Are you listening to me fucktard?"

"Not particularly," I sniped at I turned my attention to him. "Pour me a bourbon."

He gave me a phony salute as he uncorked the decanter. "What up with you? Is it Sophie? I told you, you're too fucking young to get married."

At the mention of my fiancée I yanked at the silk tie around my neck. Sophie-Ann was most definitely not the reason for me rebuffing the sexy young women's advances tonight. Although it wasn't an arranged marriage it might as well be. My family, not to mention my country and the media absolutely adored my pretty blonde fiancé. I cared for her, but love and certainly commitment weren't in the cards for us. We had an unspoken agreement that she would get to become a princess and in return she would look the other way at my infidelities. Ain't love grand?

"Unfortunately Valmont," I sighed having endured this conversation with him on numerous occasions, "Not all of us have the luxury of being a spoiled, lazy, lay about for the rest of our lives."

"Spare me," he grumbled as he handed over my drink, "Like your life is so fucking difficult. I saw you tonight. You don't even have to try. You walked into that club and already ever woman was ready to pounce on your dick. Nikolas, you don't have to settle for Sophie. You could have anyone you want."

Hmm, if only he knew. Once again my gaze lingered down the hallway towards the bedrooms. "Not everyone…"

Sebastian eyed me curiously and I realized I needed to steer this conversation in a new direction. "What about you asshole? That model was begging for you to take her home. Since when do you turn down available pussy?"

He collapsed on the lounger across from me and took a swig of his drink. "I wasn't in the mood," he drawled lazily.

I tossed my head back and let out a roar of laughter. "You're not in the mood? Since when?" I don't have any scientific proof, but I'm pretty sure Sebastian came out of the womb with a hard on. Something was most definitely up.

Studying my oldest friend I tried to decipher his angle. The thing about Valmont however was that he could be a secretive bastard when he so chose. Evidentially this was one of those times. With a dismissive wave of his hand he explained, "I have an early morning tomorrow. I promised my father I'd join him for a game of racquetball at the club."

There was a bullshit excuse if ever I heard one. Sebastian hated racquetball and any sort of physical exertion that didn't immediately service his dick. Ignoring my look of clear disbelief he prattled on, "Besides, I told you I'd see you off at the hanger. You know this might be the last time I see you before the wedding."

At the mention of my upcoming nuptials I rolled my eyes and my drug addled mind swiftly forgot our recent discussion. "Hmm…yes, you're probably right."

"I'm curious, have you sowed all your wild oats? Any sexual fantasy left unfulfilled?"

I was about to remind him that I had no intentions of staying monogamous to Sophie-Anne and that I fully intended to continue on with my debauched ways in the bedroom, when I realized this was my opportunity. Had I been fully in my right mind I would have dismissed the thought right away, but as I feeling less inhibited at the moment I seized my chance. As casually as I could muster I replied, "Actually there is one last sexual fantasy I was hoping to live out before I take my vows."

"Oh?" Sebastian eyed me over his glass studying me curiously. I gazed at him just as intently willing him to give words to what I was still too chicken shit to admit. Because he HAD to know. Sebastian was many things, but stupid and willfully ignorant wasn't one of them. He had to know what I wanted most.

Finally, breaking his gaze he chugged down the rest of his bourbon and remarked flippantly, "I'm not going to fuck you."

Then again, perhaps I overestimated his intelligence after all.

Rolling my eyes I finished my drink and shook my head at my friend's assessment. I did consider myself bi-sexual and did indulge in the occasional hard bodied male, but I had never had any sexual fantasies regarding Valmont (well maybe that's a small lie). I realized if I ever wanted my fantasy to come true I had to divulge the truth. "Please sweetheart, you'd fuck me and love every minute of it." As he chuckled I quickly added, "But actually there's another Valmont I'm interested in."

Immediately Sebastian's mood shifted and his face fell. He watched me for a beat, his face blank but his eyes hard. "I take it we're not talking about my step-mother?"

"Come on Valmont," I sighed, "You have to know I've always fancied Kathryn. She's gorgeous, intelligent and sophisticated. There's something sexy about her good-girl routine."

Quickly rising to his feet Valmont headed back to the bar. "Yeah, keyword is 'routine'. Appearances can be deceiving my friend or in my sister's case, full on bullshit."

I was curious about this. Sebastian occasionally remarked about his stepsister being a two-faced manipulator but I wasn't sure if it was true or just sibling rivalry. I had never met his version of Kathryn Merteuil, but I was intrigued.

Truth was, I had been absolutely fascinated by my friend's stepsister since he introduced her to me three years ago. The beautiful, petite, porcelain doll with the big green eyes, soft curves and beaming smile. At the time she had been fifteen to my eighteen years and I didn't much fancy the possible scandal that could arise if it got out I was messing around with an underage girl. And then there was of course the fact that she was one of my oldest friend's sisters. Back then it couldn't happen but now…

I was so lost in my thoughts I hadn't realized that Valmont had been quietly observing me for some time. "I'm curious Nicky, what would you give me if I arranged a little get together between you two?"

My mouth literally fell open at the question. That was most definitely not how I expected him to respond, but then again this was Valmont. Letting out an incredulous laugh I replied, "You're telling me you're really willing to pimp out your sister?"

His pouty lips twitched into a smirk as he shrugged. "I would if the price was right. Besides, it would be a tad hypocritical for me to be pissed at you for lusting after my sister after what went down between me and Beatrice."

At the mention of my own sister's name my face fell and I glared mutinously at my friend. What went down, as he so flippantly put it, was he seduced my sixteen year old sister and broke her heart. Bea had been a complete mess for months and Sebastian had refused to apologize to her, insisting she had thrown herself at him. Needless to say it had been a particular dark period in our friendship. Recalling Bea's tearstained face I suddenly felt less guilty about my need to fuck Kathryn.

Slamming my glass down on the table with a thud I strut up to him confidently and demanded, "Alright, let's hear it. What do you want Valmont?"

"What do you got?"

Truth be told I didn't know what I could offer that Valmont couldn't buy himself. I might be royalty, but he was heir to a billionaire. "How about my Lamborghini?"

Sebastian rolled his eyes. "Please, liked I'd trade the jag to drive that piece of Italian trash. What else you got?"

"My ski chalet is the Alps?"

"Pass"

"My Picasso?"

"I prefer Renoir"

"A night with Sophie-Anne?"

"What makes you think I haven't already had her?"

"What DO you want?"

"Another shot with Beatrice?"

I knew he was kidding, yet I was still overcome with the desire to punch him. Seeing my undoubtedly terse face he laughed. "Kidding."

"You're an asshole"

Guzzling another scotch he snickered. "Yeah, lucky for you or else I wouldn't be helping you screw my sister. Alright, here it is, I want access to Sauli for a month."

Sauli was the private island off the coast of Greece that my family owned. It was gorgeous, completely off the map and completely devoid of anyone other than the staff who ran it. No intoxicated debutantes or island bimbos for him to chase around, so I was a little confused as to his interest. "What are you planning to do on a private island all by yourself? Smoke weed and write in your queer journal? You could do that here."

A ghost of a smile graced his pretty face as he replied mysteriously, "Don't worry about it. Do we have a deal or not?"

I studied him for a long moment. Blowing off beautiful women to take me home? Wanting to spend a month on a private island alone? What the fuck wasn't he telling me? Then again, what did I care about Sebastian's secrets if I got to fuck Kathryn? Shaking his hand I grinned in triumph. "You got yourself a deal friend. However, I don't know how you're going to pull this off. Kathryn has never been receptive to my advances in the past."

Usually women fell all over themselves trying to impress me, but not Kathryn. My charm and overtures were generally met with polite smiles and doe-eyed stares. I wondered how the hell Sebastian believed he could overcome her lack of interest.

Evidentially he wasn't worried as he tossed me an arrogant half grin and sneered, "Yeah she likes to play the tease but its all bullshit."

That right there should have been the first clue of what I was walking in to, but I was just too amped up and horny to care about anything other than sinking my dick into Ms. Merteuil.

Finishing off his drink, Sebastian set down the crystal and clasped his hands together. "Alright then, shall we?"

I stopped mid sip. "Wait. Now?"

Sebastian was already heading down the hallway towards the bedrooms. "Would you prefer a quickie on the way to the airport?"

Oh yes, I nearly forgot I was heading home tomorrow. It really was now or never. Following quickly after my friend, I fell into step beside him as he approached the door. "I guess you have a point."

As Valmont raised his hand to knock on his stepsister's door I realized I had a weird fluttering inside my stomach. At first I thought it might have been the alcohol and I cursed myself for possibly ruining things before they began, but then I realized it was actually nerves. I was nervous, scared even. Christ, I couldn't recall the last time that happened. I was always in control, always cool, always confident, but now at the prospect of facing Kathryn I was a nervous wreck.

Sebastian's eyes narrowed at me. "You alright?"

I shrugged and threw him a, of course weirdo, look. Fuck, I needed to get my shit together and quick.

As I shook off my nerves Valmont knocked on the door and a moment later Kathryn called out in her melodic voice, "Come in!"

Sebastian smiled at me before opening the door and stepping inside. Squaring my shoulders I followed after him trying to appear like the arrogant, entitled, Prince I usually was. As I entered the room I nearly collapsed at the sight that greeted me.

There sat my dream girl, in her satin and silk alcove bed wearing a barely there black lace slip. Even more shocking then her provocative attire was her actions. Bent over a small mirror she gracefully snorted two lines of cocaine before popping her head up and rubbing her nose. When her eyes met mine they went wide in surprised horror. We both looked at Sebastian who just grinned smugly back at me as if to say, told you so.

"Hey sis, bad time?"

Trying her best to produce a smile she replied tentatively, "Sort of. I wasn't aware you had company. Good evening Prince Nikolas."

Giving her my most charming smile I nodded and tried my damndest not to stare at her exposed, luscious thighs. Fuck she was hot. "Please Kathryn, call me Nikolas and we didn't mean to intrude."

Sebastian rolled his eyes and sighed, "Of course we did." Strolling over to the bed he plopped down casually beside his sister and playfully swatted under her nose. "Missed some."

Kathryn slapped his hand away and glared at him mutinously. "I'm not really up for receiving visitors right now Sebastian. It's late."

"Come on sis," Sebastian purred as he gently brushed a strand of her silky chestnut hair behind her ear, "Be nice. We wouldn't want the Prince to think we're rude."

I watched as the pair stared at one another intently for a long moment as if they were having some sort of wordless conversation. I shifted uncomfortably suddenly feeling like I was intruding on something.

Leaning back on her arms Kathryn looked over at me and smiled in a way she had never done before. It wasn't shy or coy or sweet. It was feral, teasing and sexy as fuck. "So, did you boys have fun tonight?"

"Sure"

"It was alright"

"Then why did you come home alone?" Turning her eyes on her brother she taunted, "What's the matter Valmont? Did the roofies not work this time?"

Leaning against the opposite end of the bed I chuckled at the scowl that suddenly overcame Valmont's usually arrogant face. "I've never had to drug anyone for sex in my life."

"Yeah, tell that to the school nurse darling," Kathryn laughed. I joined in her laughter. It was fun seeing someone else knock Valmont off his self imposed pedestal.

However, I should have remembered that Sebastian didn't usually tolerate being laughed at. His scowl soon turned into a malicious grin aimed squared at me. "Actually sis, Prince Nik came home early because he was hoping to fuck you."

Glaring back at Valmont I expected Kathryn to appear shocked or at the very least offended, but instead she just raised an eyebrow at me and inquired, "What makes you think I'd agree to that?"

Before I could reply, tell her Valmont was just joking, lying, anything, Sebastian swiped a finger through the cocaine and answered, "How about because you're all coked up and have no one to fuck."

"There are ways around that," came her dry reply.

"Yes, but I imagine his dick is more appealing than your vibrator," he explained as he gestured in my direction. "Oh come on sis, throw him a bone."

Valmont grinned back at me like a little boy clearly enjoying his stupid pun. I just shook my head and rolled my eyes at him. Was this seriously how he was going to help me nail his sister? Why did I think this would work? I was desperately wishing he would just leave already. Honestly, couldn't he see he was just making things worse?

"What makes you think I don't have plans with someone else?"

The teasing smile he had been wearing suddenly melted away and Sebastian once again became serious. His hand reached out and caressed his stepsister's naked thigh. "Plans can be changed," he explained in a coaxing, seductive tone.

What the fuck? It took a moment for my brain to process what I was seeing in front of me. Valmont, with his hand on his sisters naked thigh in a completely comfortable and judging by the look on Kathryn's face, not unwelcome manor. This thing I had witnessed between them, the raised eyebrows, the smirks, the taunting, wasn't typical sibling bratty behavior. It was sexual tension.

Now I had witness my fair share of deplorable behavior before (and even participated in a lot of it) but lusting after your own sister? That was fucked up. But then again this was Sebastian Valmont, the man who ruined my sister for sport, who stole mistresses out from under his own father, who lost his virginity at twelve to his au pair. Of course Sebastian was fucking his stepsister.

Observing the pair as they gazed at one another intently I wondered if it was more than just fucking. Some of Sebastian's odd behavior this past week made me wonder what was truly going on between them and why the hell he invited me into the middle of it, for suddenly I felt like an intruder. If Valmont was playing some game I wasn't interested in being his pawn.

Clearing my throat, I reminded them of my presence before I said, "Perhaps this was a bad idea. If you'll excuse me I'll bid you two goodnight."

"Wait," Kathryn called out as she tore her glance from her stepbrother and looked at me. Moving her drugs out of the way she sensuously crawled to the edge of the bed giving me a good idea of just how small that slip she was wearing was. Rising up on her knees so we were at eyelevel she licked her lips and gave me a small grin before capturing my mouth in a kiss.

There was nothing tentative or shy about the way Kathryn kissed me. This was a girl who knew exactly what she was doing, did it well and demanded that you keep up. As her clever tongue clashed against mine she grasped the lapels of my jacket and tore it off me. I clutched her petite form and let my hands roam over her body touching her wherever I could. Her skin was so soft I couldn't tell where her slip ended and her skin began.

I wasn't sure if I pushed her back into the bed or she pulled me down. The next thing I knew I was on top of her, our mouths still fused together, as I ground my pelvis against her, eager to relieve some of the tension in my groin.

I'll admit I was so involved in our little make-out session that I completely forgot about Valmont's presence. It was only when I heard him light up a smoke that I realized he was still there, but I honestly I could give a fuck. Let the bastard videotape it for all I cared.

With surprising force Kathryn abruptly pushed me off her and then quickly straddled me. She regarded me with a sexy smile as she started unbuttoning my dress shirt. As if suddenly recalling our audience she looked over at her stepbrother and asked, "Are you planning on watching us pervert?"

"Well you know me sis, I love a good show." As if for emphasis he rubbed his cock through his pants.

Kathryn's eyes darkened in lust as she replied, "Yes, but not half as much as you love participating"

"Is that an invitation?"

"Perhaps"

Unable to keep quiet any longer I yelled out completely exasperated, "Exactly what the FUCK have I walked in on?"

The pair stared back at my blankly before Kathryn climbed off my lap and returned back to her drugs. As I watched her make lines out of her small pile of coke, it occurred to me I wasn't going to get an answer from them. Clearly it either wasn't something they discussed or it wasn't considered my business.

Kathryn bent over to snort a line and Sebastian reached out and held her hair back for her. As she sat up he grasped the flimsy straps of her nightgown and gently tugged it down to her waist effectively putting her breasts on display. Glancing over at me Sebastian drawled, "Nikki, doesn't my sis have the prettiest titties around?"

Really, I should have just gotten the fuck out of there, but one look at a half naked Kathryn and I knew I wasn't going anywhere. Sebastian's games be damned. I wanted her and if I had to deal with Valmont so be it.

Moving closer to them I reached out and palmed her tit. "They're lovely," I agreed and it wasn't an empty compliment. I had seen my fair share of breasts in my day but Kathryn's were beautiful. Not huge but a nice handful, full and firm. To top it off she had perfect pink nipples already standing at attention.

As Sebastian toyed with her right one I leaned forward and took her left nipple into my mouth, delighting in the texture of her skin. Kathryn gasped at my ministrations and fell against her stepbrother. However, as I looked up, it was me she was eyeing with lust. I suppose that was a small victory in all this.

Taking her by the thighs Sebastian gently untangled Kathryn's legs and positioned her so her thighs were open in front of me. "Show our guest your tight little cunt Kathryn," he instructed in a seductive whisper.

Pulling my mouth away I sat back and watched as she pulled the flimsy material of her underwear aside and exposed her damp slit. Without instruction I let my fingers graze her pussy and was delighted to feel how wet she was. My eyes met hers as I slowly inserted my finger. Fuck, she was tight.

"Do you want him to fuck you?" Sebastian asked her but his eyes remained on me.

Kathryn whimpered and replied, "I want you both to fuck me."

My stare met Valmont's who raised a challenging eyebrow my way. I wondered if this was his plan all along. Knowing him as I did I realize he had probably been manipulating me the whole time. I should probably have been furious, but I found I was just too horny to care.

"Well it wasn't the arrangement, but what the hell?" I replied trying my best to sound nonchalant even though I currently had my finger buried in my dream girls cunt and had just agreed to a threesome with her stepbrother. Well, in anything this would certainly go down as one of the weirdest nights I'd spent.

Removing my hand from her pussy, Kathryn straightened herself out and looked back and forth between me and Sebastian. "Okay, you two are wearing entirely too many clothes. Strip."

With a lazy grin Valmont began tugging off his clothes and I did the same. Kathryn turned my way and unfastened my belt. As she did she looked up at me through coy lashes and teased, "You know I've always wondered how you were in bed. Are you as good as they say?"

Grinning cockily I replied, "Better."

With a violent tug she removed my pants. "Then you better not disappoint me."

Now completely naked, Sebastian came up behind his sister and tugged her indecent slip all the way off her body. Turning around his face him, Kathryn rose up on her knees and placed her hands on his shoulders for balance. Once again the pair stared at each other in that same intense, burning way that made me feel as if I didn't exist. A feeling I was very foreign with.

Wanting a distraction, I eyed Kathryn's cocaine before leaning over and snorting a line. Kathryn looked my way and smiled, obviously pleased by my indulgence. Pulling away from her stepbrother she joined me and sniffed a line.

Sebastian groaned, "Kathryn, watch it with that stuff."

Ignoring her brother's warning she looked up at me and mocked, "Isn't it cute? He thinks he's in charge."

"I'm not taking your ass to the hospital again, I mean it.'

Looking up at my friend I was startled to see the concern etched on his face. I had never seen Valmont care about anything outside of his jag. Kathryn was either oblivious or didn't care about his concern. Rolling her eyes she huffed, "Whatever."

Sebastian reached out and smacked her bare ass. "What was that?"

She jumped at the hit and whipped around to face him. Rising on her knees so they were back at eye level, she wrapped her arms around his neck. "Sorry daddy," she mockingly replied.

Sebastian kissed her cheek and praised, "That's my good girl."

Watching this exchange with horror and a little bit of lust I told them, "You two are seriously fucked up."

Kathryn let out a mischievous little giggle and winked at me before turning her attention back on her brother. "Come on Sebastian, do a little. For me?"

She flicked her tongue across his lips and then grasped his hard-on which was already standing at full mass. My own dick got even harder (if that was possible) as I watched her work him over. This newfound aspect of their relationship might annoy me, but I had to admit they were hot together.

"Alright, fine," Sebastian huffed as he knelt down and snorted a line. As I watched, it occurred to me that in all our years I don't think I had ever seen Valmont do coke. Pot, ecstasy, pills and on one occasion mushrooms, but never cocaine. I guess Kathryn really did have him wrapped around her finger.

The drugs were making their way through my system and were making me horny and anxious to get things started. As Kathryn took a seat beside me I pulled her into another kiss which she eagerly returned. Sick of waiting, I gently pushed her onto her back and spread her legs.

"Someone's impatient," she clucked.

Getting down on my belly (wincing when my hard cock rubbed against the mattress) I positioned myself between her open legs and eyed her cunt appreciably. "Enough with the teasing. I came here to fuck."

Kathryn toyed with her own nipple as she bit her lip in anticipation. "Yes your highness," she mocked.

I winked at her before leaning forward to begin the task at hand. She really did have quite a lovely little pussy. Completely hairless and a pretty shade of pink. As I took my time parting her folds I delighted in the way she twitched in obvious eagerness.

Usually, I could take or leave eating a girl out. It wasn't my favorite thing, but not unpleasant either. Yet now I found myself desperate for it. As I began licking her slit and burying my tongue in her tight little hole I found I couldn't get enough. Little mews and gasps of pleasure emerged from Kathryn as she grasped me by the hair and ground herself against my face.

"God damn Nikolas," she moaned.

When I started tonguing her clit she could no longer stay still. I held her down with one hand and I looked up to find Sebastian to ask him to hold her still. However, Valmont was busy with his own task. He had taken some cocaine from a vile and had dumped a small amount between his stepsister's breasts. As he bent down to snort it he ordered her, "Hold still Kathryn. I don't want to spill."

She let out a throaty laugh that turned into a moan as I let my teeth graze her clit. "I can't, he's eating me so good."

I felt an obvious rush of pride upon hearing her words. Looking up at her, with my mouth still working her sex, our eyes met and I swear I felt my dick twitch. When I felt her muscles start to constrict I brought two fingers to her clenching hole and pumped them inside. Kathryn let out a loud, lusty, moan as she started to cum but it was suddenly silenced when Sebastian kissed her. I watched annoyed as the pair began making out.

Breaking apart Kathryn's eyes never left her brother as she sighed, "Thank you."

Yep, leave it to Valmont to take credit for my work. Asshole. I glared over at him but he just grinned back obviously satisfied by this move.

Kathryn was either oblivious to the tension or didn't care as she called out, "Okay who's going to fuck me first?" Sebastian opened his mouth to speak but she quickly shut him down by adding, "And so help me god, if I hear the term 'sloppy seconds' from either of you assholes I will lock myself in the bathroom and neither of you will get any pussy, got it?"

Judging by the completely unamused look she was giving both of us I could tell she meant business. "Got it," I agreed.

Sebastian just chuckled, clearly use to Kathryn's mood swings, and nodded at me. "Since Nikolas is our guest of honor, he can go first."

I eyed my rival, as I was now coming to see him, with suspicion but didn't voice it. Kathryn just smiled up at me and made herself comfortable on her back. Out of the corner of my eye I saw Valmont reach into a drawer inside the alcove and pull out a few condoms. I didn't want to think about how he knew they were there. He handed one to me and as I put it on I noticed not for the first time that nigh,t that my dick was roughly the same size as Sebastian's. I suppose there was one less thing I didn't have to worry about tonight.

Leaning forward I kissed Kathryn and murmured, "You ready sweetheart?"

Her eyes seemed to twinkle with merriment as she replied, "Oh yeah, fuck me good."

Oh I planned too. Taking my dick in hand I rubbed it up and down her twat, letting it grind against her clit, causing Kathryn to whimper with need. "Nikolas," she cooed, "stop teasing I want it in me."

"You heard the lady," Sebastian replied as he watched with curious eyes as I started to penetrate his stepsister.

Rather than inch it in slow I purposely thrust in hard, figuring Kathryn would prefer that to slow and gentle. Judging by the gasp of pleasure I was met with I assumed correctly. Her back arched as she met my thrust eagerly.

Not waiting for her to catch her breath, I began driving into her mercilessly. She was as tight as I always hoped and felt better than I could have imagined. It was also possible she was more responsive than any girl or woman for that matter I had fucked before.

Of course Sebastian couldn't be left out of things for long. He knelt down besides Kathryn's face and she wasted no time taking his swollen cock into her eager mouth. It should have annoyed me that he was hoarding in on my turf, but honestly it was hot watching her take both our dicks at once. Clutching her chestnut hair Valmont fucked her mouth as I pounded her pussy.

Sebastian chuckled, "I think she likes this."

"I think you're right"

Pulling the appendage from her mouth she scowled at both of us and hissed, "Shut up and make me cum."

Not wanting to be the first to shoot my wad, I toyed with Kathryn's clit, pleased when I found her dripping all over the place.

"Come on sis," Sebastian panted obviously close himself. "Cum all over that dick. I want to see you cum hard."

Moments later I felt her cunt tighten around me as her screams were muffled by her stepbrother's member stuffed down her throat. My own orgasm came barreling forward. I clutched her tightly to me, enough to leave bruises, before shooting into the rubber. With a sharp groan Sebastian came as well. Kathryn swallowing his seed.

Feeling slightly lightheaded, I gently pulled out of her cozy cunt and collapsed beside her. Sebastian fell back against the pillows obviously exhausted as well. The three of us lay there a few minutes catching our breaths before Kathryn turned onto her stomach and regarded us with annoyance. "That better not have been it, otherwise I will be extremely disappointed in you two."

I couldn't help but chuckle at her exasperated tone. Sebastian just shook his head at me as if to say, welcome to my world. "Demanding little bitch isn't she? Why don't we give the princess what she wants?"

And we did. When we finally got a second wing, Sebastian proceeded to fuck her doggy style while Kathryn blew me. And fuck me, could that girl suck cock. If I hadn't been half in love with her already I would have been by the time I shot my cum down her throat.

I watched transfixed as Sebastian whispered something in his sister's ear after he came that made her blush. Given the fact that she had just spent the past hour fucking two guys at once I wondered what he could have possibly said.

Valmont placed a kiss on Kathryn's back before climbing off the bed. I took one of his cigarettes and lit up as he headed to the door. "I'm going to get us some refreshments," he called out before exiting, not bothering to put a stitch of clothing on before he did.

"Give me a drag," the petite beauty demanded when we were alone. I smiled as Kathryn maneuvered her head into my lap. I brought the cigarette to her lips.

We enjoyed a moment of comfortable silence before I asked her the question that had been nagging at me since this night began. "Kathryn, I've been wondering, how come you never returned my advances before?"

She gave a coy little shrug and replied, "I wasn't aware you were interested."

"Bullshit"

"I don't know, you always had some girl or another hanging on you…how is Sophie-Ann by the way?"

I smirked at her attempt to change the subject. "She's on the other side of the world. Answer me. Did Valmont have something to do with it?"

Kathryn sighed, "He might have asked me to stay away from you."

"I thought as much. Tell me, do you always do what your brother asks?"

"Of course not," she snapped. "However in this instance he was rather…insistent."

"I see." I wondered then if Valmont knew all along that I had a thing for his stepsister. Had he just been waiting all this time for me to voice my desires? This line of thought of course led to the other question I had been pondering. "How long have you been sleeping with Sebastian?"

A ghost of a smile crossed her face as she opened her mouth to reply. Before I could get my answer Sebastian came strutting into the room with a bottle of Cristal his hard dick swinging elegantly between his legs. "I think I have an idea for the grand finale," he announced as he handed me over the bottle.

Kathryn's eyes didn't leave me as she replied, "Oh?"

Judging by the shit eating grin he was wearing it was something good. He lay down beside his stepsister and brushed the hair from her face. "I want Nikolas to fuck your pussy while I take your ass."

For the first time that evening Kathryn appeared to be taken back. Her bright green eyes went wide at Valmont's words. Sitting up she replied warily, "I don't think so."

Going by her reaction I assumed it was something she had never done before. I had a few times before and found it to be pleasurably intense if the girl was also into it. The thought of taking Kathryn that way got me hard immediately, but I wasn't interested if she didn't want to. I wondered if Valmont would push his sister into something she didn't want.

I watched as Sebastian cupped her face and drew her close. "Come on baby," he whispered, "It will be hot. Both of us in you at the same time. Think of how full you'll be, how wet…"

Under Valmont's touch Kathryn seemed to melt on the spot. I was shocked. I assumed it was Kathryn who held all the cards in this twisted relationship, but perhaps I was wrong. Maybe Sebastian was the dominant one of the pair.

Kathryn was quiet a minute before murmuring softly, "Alright, let's do it."

Sebastian grinned and winked over at me. "That's my girl."

Slowly the docile expression left Kathryn's face and was replaced with a sinister smirk as she added, "But I want something in return."

"I should have known that was too easy," he remarked dryly.

"Silly rabbit, you really think I'm going to roll over and let you defile me in anyway you please without a little compensation?" Kathryn bit her stepbrother's pouty lip and chastised, "You're smarter than that Valmont."

"What do you want?"

Clearly nothing pleasant if that grin she was sporting was any indication. "Hmm…what I want if for you and Prince Nikolas to put on a show for me."

Sebastian cocked an eyebrow. "Put on a show?"

"Yes, I want to see you two handsome young men get each other off,"

"Excuse me?"

I let out a bark of laughter and exclaimed, "Well done sweetheart. I couldn't think of a more appropriate trade."

Valmont whipped his head back at me and sneered, "Of course you have no problem with this. I know you've wanted to fuck me for years!"

When Kathryn regarded me with surprise I explained, "Yes, I'm bi darling. But I've never much fancied Valmont…no matter what his over blown ego believes."

"Well aren't you just full of surprises," she laughed.

"Right back at you Ms. Merteuil," I replied with a wink.

Valmont looked back and forth between us with a look of disgust. "Oh, for crying out loud," he exclaimed before reaching for me suddenly and planting a very passionate, none too tentative kiss on my lips.

Needless to say I was more than a little taken aback by this sudden action. I had never taken Sebastian for a homophobe, but then again he had always given off the distinct impression of having absolutely no interest in the male gender. However, judging by was expert way he was kissing me I knew this wasn't his first time. I had kissed my fair share of straight boys and I knew from experience that Valmont was no novice.

As we broke apart for air I looked into my oldest friends face and saw a mixture of defiance and lust that made me laugh. "Well, well it looks like you've been holding out on me," I teased. "I always assumed you were a virgin to homosexual sex Valmont."

Out of the corner of my eye I noticed Kathryn, whose eyes were as wide as saucers upon our kiss, break into a large grin. "Have you been having pillow kissing sessions with Tuttle, Sebastian?"

The pretty boy rolled his eyes at us and exclaimed, "Fuck you both. Yes, I've been with a guy once or twice. No, it wasn't Tuttle," he snapped irritated. "I told you I'd try anything once."

"Really?" I asked intrigued.

"I'm not fucking you"

"Suck me off?"

When he shook his head no, Kathryn offered, "Hand job with tongue?"

"That is a blow job. Look, I'm not sucking off someone I use to take baths with when I was two. It's too weird."

I laughed at this. "Oh, but fucking your sister is completely normal."

With a lazy, predatory grin he eyed his sister and replied, "Fuck yeah. Look at her. Look how fucking sexy she is." Kathryn smirked back at us as she causally massaged her breasts.

"She certainly is," I agreed.

"I like a compliment as much as the next girl, but less talking more playing. I want to see you two jerk each other off. Hard." As he left hand moved to her open thighs she added, "Make it hot for me."

"As you wish," he murmured before pulling me back into another intense kiss.

Those pillowy, soft, cocksucker lips were just as good and I always imagined. It was true I had never openly lusted after Valmont, he was far too alpha male for my taste, but I had always been curious what it would be like to play a round of mattress tag with him. Feeling his tongue push demandingly into my mouth and the crush of his rock hard groin to mine had me eager to go beyond simple hand jobs, but I wasn't about to push.

Sebastian made his move first, grabbing by throbbing dick in a tight, gruff fist. I groaned into his mouth at his touch and eagerly grabbed his cock. Fuck it was nice. Clearly he thought so as well, as I felt him tremble under my grip.

Our kisses became sloppier and were soon just a mess of teeth and tongue, clashing together as we furiously jacked each other off. Even in my haze of lust I was dimly aware of the soft pants of pleasure that was coming from my other bedmate. I glanced over at Kathryn and what I saw made my grip on Valmont tighten even more. She lay against the pillows, legs crudely spread as she thrust two fingers quickly in and out of her snatch while her thumb rubbed at her clit. Her hooded gaze was completely glued to us.

"Enjoying yourself?" I managed to grit out through my pleasure.

"Hell yes, but I suspect not as much as you are," Kathryn laughed.

Sebastian, whose forehead was resting against my own, looked towards his stepsister and grinned. "You gonna cum sis?"

"You first," she panted, "Jerk that beautiful dick hard Valmont."

He took instruction well, as his grip tightened on me. A moment later I felt him tug at my balls. I groaned and bit his shoulder causing him to mutter curses under his breath. "You close old friend?" I asked in my native tongue.

"Yeah," he groaned, "I just need…"

I had a pretty good idea what he needed. Reaching around I palmed that beautiful ass of his and then ran a finger down his crack. I waited a beat to see if he would tense up or freak out at what I was about to do, but Sebastian just moaned a bit my neck. Without hesitation I let my finger rub against his puckered hole before sliding it in. I didn't even have to touch his prostate before he was shooting off across my chest with a feral cry. The sight and sounds he made were enough to send me over the edge as well. I groaned out as my seed spurted out all over Valmont's fist.

"Oh god, fuck," Kathryn cursed. I tore the eyes away from Sebastian's chest and watched as she came withering against he pillows. An erotic sight if ever there was one.

As the three of us took a moment to catch our collective breaths, Kathryn let out a husky laugh. "Thanks guys, that was…impressive. I don't think I'm going to forget that anytime soon."

Sebastian looked up at her and warned, "I would if I were you."

She grinned back at him obviously not fazed by his warning. Crawling over to the two of us she gently pushed us on to our backs and began licking cum off our chests. I had already cum three times that evening and already I was hard again. Incredible.

Valmont's eyes met mine and he smiled. "You still want to tell me how fuck up I am for wanting her?"

I just grinned as I watched her lick the remaining jizz from my chest. When she was finished with us, she sat up and rubbed her mouth. "Yummy. Now, if you'll give me a minute I'm going to freshen up and then we can begin the grand finale."

The two of us watched as she sashayed over to the bathroom and closed the door. We were silent for a moment and then looked at each other and laugh. What else could we do? I had plenty of sex in my life but never with anyone I've known since I was in diapers.

Sitting up we both had a glass of champagne and a cigarette. "So are you ready for this?" I asked him.

"Of course," he replied with his usual air of indifference. "However, I think we should set a few ground rules."

"Such as?"

Valmont reached over and put out his smoke. "For starters you're not getting anywhere near her ass."

I chuckled, "I wasn't aware you were so territorial Sebastian."

"Only about certain things," he replied vaguely. "Besides, it's not about that. I don't trust anyone outside myself with that. Kathryn's more delicate that she seems."

I frowned, suddenly annoyed by what he was insinuating. "You actually think I would hurt her?"

"Not intentionally. But we've both taken all sorts of shit tonight and I know how that can impair one's judgment."

"Right"

"I'm not fucking around," he stated, all humor now gone from his voice. "You fucking hurt her and I'll kill you Nikolas. She's not some piece of ass you came bruise and leave. I'm telling you right now; if she asks at any time to stop you damn well better pull out. I don't care if you're two seconds away from coming, got it?"

I looked back at him rather stunned. In all the time I had known him I'm never known Valmont to take anything seriously or care deeply about anything. Part of me wanted to put him in his place for dare suggesting that I would or could hurt Kathryn, but another part, the curious part, had another question in mind.

"I understand Valmont. So tell me, how long have you been in love with her?"

Just as I suspected, he flinched at the allegation. Producing the air of indifference he usually wore he replied, "I'm not."

"You're lying. I know you, remember? You're in love with her."

Looking me dead in the eye he replied coolly, "And you're not?"

Touché.

Before I could open my mouth to respond the bathroom door opened and Kathryn emerged smelling like Channel #5 and wearing a sexy grin. She crawled back onto the bed between us. Sebastian reached out for her, tenderly taking her by the neck and nuzzling his nose against her ear. "You ready for us baby?"

"Uh-huh," she replied her eyes on mine as her stepbrother kissed her neck.

Taking the lead, I laid out on my back and took her by the waist. Valmont handed me a condom and I put it on as Kathryn straddled me. He came up behind her and rubbed her stomach, her tits, her back. Leaning in closer he whispered something to her I couldn't make out. She chuckled lightly and I once again found myself deeply annoyed. I got it, they were close. Why was the son of a bitch delighting in rubbing it in my face?

It was childish, but I couldn't help but want my own moment of tenderness with Kathryn even though I realized at this point I could never have what they had. Reaching for her, I brought her in close and whispered, "You don't have to do this darling if you don't want to. Fuck Valmont."

She simply laughed. "But Nikki that's what I plan on doing. I'm going to fuck you both and it's going to be good." She drew out that last word in a purr then leaned down and flicked her tongue against my lip causing my dick to twitch.

Well fuck it then, onward and upward.

Lifting her up, I guided her over my swollen shaft and slowly brought her down. As I penetrated her she made a kneeing sound in the back of her throat. Resting her hands atop my chest for balance she took a moment to adjust to having me inside her before moving. I was grateful as I loved the luxurious feeling of being buried deep inside her.

Soon she was riding me at a slow, tantalizing pace. Gripping her thighs I watched entranced as her tits bobbed and her hair flew in her face. Sebastian stood behind her with a bottle of massage oil. "You better not fuck this up and shoot your wad before I can get inside her," Valmont sniffed.

"I'm sorry asshole, who came first last time?"

He gave me the finger behind his stepsister's back. "Jesus Christ," Kathryn groaned, "You two bicker like a couple of old women. Just fuck each other and get it over with…oh wait." She erupted in laughed and Sebastian responded by slapping her ass. "Ouch!" she called out and rode me harder.

However, when Sebastian began playing with her ass she slowed down. I couldn't see what he was doing, but judging the dark look that came over her pretty face she was enjoying it. "You like that baby?" Valmont murmured to her, "You like having your ass played with?"

"Sebastian," she whispered as she ground her pelvis against mine. "Fuck, that feel nice."

"I'd rim you but I'm afraid our foreign friend won't last long."

"Blow me," I snarled.

"You ready for my cock in your ass?" Kathryn looked over her shoulder at him and he kissed her with surprising gentleness given what we were about to do. "Alright, I'll go slow. If it gets too much tell me and I'll stop, got it?" When she didn't audibly reply he snapped, "Kathryn answer me."

"Yes, Christ already just put it in!"

Sebastian smacked her ass once more then slowly started penetrating her. Once again I couldn't see him enter her (which was a shame) but it was written all over her face. Kathryn was biting her lip so hard it looked like she could draw blood. "Kathryn, are you okay?"

"Yeah," she panted, "Just…g-go slow. Oh god."

When he got about half way in I groaned myself as I felt his dick through the thin wall inside her that separated us. At the same time Kathryn's pussy muscles tightened around me making her that much tighter. "Shit," I groaned, "She's tight as hell this way."

Kathryn was whimpering and shaking by the time Valmont was completely buried inside her ass. I gently cupped her cheek and asked, "Are you ready to move?"

She gave me a shaky nod and I looked up at Valmont who wore a grimace of pleasure and smiled. He placed a kiss on his stepsister's shoulder then slowly began to move. I groaned as I felt him retreat and had to will myself not to come.

In no time we found a cohesive rhythm, see-sawing back and forth inside her. Both of us had our hands all over her silky flesh as if we couldn't get enough. I know I couldn't. Her back, her thighs, and her breasts, anywhere I could get my hands I did. Kathryn was groaning and clawing at my chest. I could see a tear forming in her eye but at the same time she wore a small smile. It was intense but she was enjoying it.

"I feel so fucking full…" she moaned. "God harder, I'm going to cum again."

We sped up and soon she was quaking around us and crying out our names. Even when she came we still didn't let up and continued fucking her at the same rhythm. "You two are going to kill me," she wined.

"That's the idea love," I whispered. "You feel…incredible"

Of course I had done double penetration before but never like this. Never this intense and never with someone like Kathryn. Someone I wanted so badly.

I knew I was on the verge of coming as was Valmont judging by his erratic thrusts. I brought my hand to Kathryn's cunt and gently tugged at her nub. Soon I felt Sebastian's hand join me, rubbing where we were joined. Kathryn's groan's got louder as she bent over on my chest and buried her face in my neck.

"Come on baby," Valmont coaxed, his own voice hoarse from exhaustion. "Let go, let that little pussy cum."

Moments later she finally came shaking and whimpering against my neck. However, it wasn't my name she was saying. "Sebastian, Sebastian, God Sebastian," she babbled over and over in a tiny voice I'm not really sure he even heard.

It gutted me somewhat knowing it was him she was thinking of during this intense moment of pleasure. I was inside her as well and I was the one she was cuddled against, but all she could think of was him. This dark thought seemed like it should lessen my pleasure somewhat but it didn't. I came harder than I had all night. Probably harder than I had in years.

Sebastian and I seemed to shoot off simultaneously inside her. I yelled her name as I came as did he. Slowly Sebastian pulled out of her ass, but Kathryn stayed nestled against my chest. I had no problem with this but evidentially he did. "Pull out," he mouthed to me. I scowled but reluctantly did as he asked.

As soon as we were separated Valmont scooped her up in his arms and laid her down on her pillow. Sitting up I lit a cigarette and watched fascinated as my lothario friend catered to his stepsister. He fetched a washcloth and a bottle of water and cleaned her up and forced her to drink. Kathryn half heartedly teased him the whole time but secretly I could tell she was enjoying his attention. Once, she glanced over at me and smiled but soon her attention was back on him.

I was starting to feel more and more like the third wheel, but I was reluctant to leave. It was like leaving meant I was giving up on some dream I knew was never to be. I would never be with Kathryn, she would never be mine. I might have 'had' her but that was a lie. I could never have her when she so obviously and completely belonged to someone else.

"Alright sis, time to say goodnight to Nicky." Sebastian's voice woke me from my thoughts. Apparently I was being dismissed. Part of me wanted to fight him on it but I didn't really have a leg to stand on. I had no rights over her.

I got up and put my pants on and threw my shirt on but didn't bother buttoning it. With my jacket bent over my arm I dipped down and placed a gently kiss on the lovely brunette's lips. "Thank you Kathryn, that was amazing," I murmured.

She gave me a lazy grin and kissed my cheek. "It was amazing. Sophie-Ann is a lucky girl."

I simply nodded and then in my native tongue I told her, "Perhaps we'll do this again someday, beautiful girl."

I was fairly certain Kathryn didn't speak my language, but she smiled anyway as if she knew what I was saying. Valmont on the other hand most definitely did and gave me a sour look before getting to his feet.

Without a word we both headed to the door. Sebastian had slipped on a silk robe and as he opened the door he leaned against the doorway with his arms crossed. I nodded at him and started to leave when he pulled me back. "Um, isn't there a matter of payment to discuss?"

I had nearly forgotten that all of this started as a deal between friends. "Oh yes," I sighed, "Though, this wasn't exactly what we agreed upon."

Valmont's eyes darkened. "You got more than your money's worth. The island?"

"Will we available to you whenever you want it," I informed him. Glancing over at Kathryn, who now appeared to be asleep, something occurred to me. "You're planning on taking her, aren't you?"

He shrugged casually, "I think it will make a nice graduation gift, don't you? Besides, Kathryn loves Greece."

"Right, well, perhaps I'll drop in on you two."

Sebastian shook his head. "I don't think so. This was a one time deal Nikolas. I was just helping her live out a fantasy."

"So I was just your sex toy for the night?" I asked bitterly.

"If you want to look at it that way," he shrugged.

"You know you don't deserve her right?"

"And you do?" Sebastian took a step closer, all humor vanishing from his pretty-boy face. "Just to make it clear, Kathryn is mine. I've known how you felt about her for quite some time, but it's never going to happen. I won't let you or anyone else, take her away from me."

I tried my best to mask my surprise at his words, but I'm afraid I failed. "My, this is a new side to you my old friend." I sighed knowing when I've been beat and took one last glance at our girl. "Well just so you know I don't think you have anything to worry about. Clearly she feels the same for you."

Sebastian looked over at Kathryn and smiled slightly. "We're completely fucked up. We'll probably destroy each other."

"But what a way to go"

THE END

Author's Note: So yay, an update. Sorry for the long wait but I don't know, I just wasn't feeling it lately. But I've been reading fic for the last couple weeks and felt inspired so here we are. Hopefully I'll get a little better at updating, in the meantime thanks for all the reviews and interest.

Coming up next…F is for Faithless. It's sort of an alternate ending to the film. What happens if Sebastian didn't die, but continued on with a relationship with Annette and how Kathryn inevitably worms her way into things. After that you'll get Serial Killers Sebastian AND Kathryn. Should be fun. Until then drop me a review and let me know what you think.
- 4
- 5
- 6
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

Cruel Love Anthology