Click Here!

  • 1

Reviews for Whispers of Redemption

By : GeorgieFain
  • From TheCrimsonWing on July 15, 2007
    -=Incoherent squealing noise=- That's exciting!!! ALL OF IT! That was awesome. Superb. Fantastic. Freaking glorious to the max.

    I loved it. Every little bit of it. Will we get to see how that 'mutiny' plays out in the sequel? Hmm, I wonder. Either way, I'm ENTHRALLED that there's going to be a sequel. Many cookies, many thanks, and many stalkings have been earned
    Report Review

  • From ikkin88 on July 13, 2007
    I don't often leave comments for fics I read, mainly because I don't have any advice or anything better to say other then "ZOMG HOT!!" And that just doesn't help in the slightest even if the Authors lurv feedback. But then there are the stories that stand out that I HAVE to comment on and put some thought into it because they are so wonderfully done and deserve it! I read "Wi` A Wannion" And I loved it, truly. Maybe only the 4-5th Jack/Barbossa story I've read and one of the best. The effort and thought you've put into it with the back stories and the going ons between the movies and the scenes. And this current fic is the same, if not better. I look forward to further chapters. Also, because I'm more of an artist then a writer I felt inspired to draw your young Jack and Barbossa. It's hard to describe but I do see them in a different way and I feel a need to draw them, it's odd. Ah wells, enough of my rambling its late. Thank you. :D

    -Nikki-
    Report Review

  • From OverlookedFile on July 12, 2007
    I've read all you've got posted on this story and all I can really think is "Oi! I was readin' that!" lol. It's as bad a someone ripping a novel out of your hands mid-sentence and tossing it out the car window (had that happen- wasn't thrilled to say the least.) I love your writing, both the style and the pairing, so I wish you the best of luck in finding the time and inspiration to continue. *nod of respect*
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on July 06, 2007
    Hi!
    In light of the last chapter, I thought I'd review again, you know, show a little support.
    The Jack/Henriette thing actually went a lot more smoothly than I had expected. Well, to this point at least. I'm a little afraid of what's going to happen if (when) Henriette finds out that Jack and Barbossa have had (and hopefully will eventually reclaim!) a pretty serious relationship. As for how Barbossa himself responds to this... Well, I'm really looking forward to that!
    For now, I will continue to compulsively refresh the site, awaiting your next update.

    Report Review

  • From TheCrimsonWing on July 06, 2007
    ...I hope you weren't apologizing for my review.... DID I EVEN REVIEW?! Oh my. Well, either way, of course I mind what happened but at the same time I DON'T mind because I'm aware of things like that happening and...come on, it's good for the plot...
    I think it's a bad sign that I still disowned my Jack pillow until they make up though xD Oh well. He can LIVE WITH IT!

    ... -=Dork=-


    Report Review

  • From TheCrimsonWing on July 05, 2007
    WHOOT, I finally remembered the mentioning of 'sequel' or something and found this...read it all in two days (glad my last review made you happy ^^) and...

    OH GOD WHY?!?!?!?!?!?!?!? It's so good I sat there and stared at the screen for quite some time hoping it was a terrible horrible not very good joke. But it didn't go away. -=Squirms=- That...was...just... GAAAH! Not gonna beg for updates, naturally, that'd be stupid, so instead I give you props and cookies for the two chapters before this one and a mini-cookie for this one because...I'm pouting so mini-cookie is all I could make.

    ....Will not...stab... anything... Oh, and uh, by the way... You shouldn't sell out.... ever >>. Hah, okay. Happy..living? Yes. Happy living x3
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on June 27, 2007
    I registerd at this site just so I could review your stories. In the past few days I have read and reread both this and "Wi' A Wannion," and I love both. After watching AWE I looked all over for Barbossa/Jack fic, and feel extremely lucky to have found two such great stories.
    In your opening notes you asked for plotline contributions, and while I don't really have one of those, I do have a question I hope to maybe see addressed. I've never been a big Bootstrap Bill fan, (actually, I really disliked him in the movies) but I think you write him very well. He isn't this wonderful, super, exceptional person that everyone is always going on about in your fics, which is a breath of fresh air. However, considering he's still sort-of-alive, I'd like to see some interaction with him (assuming there's any place for the Flying Dutchman's crew in your current story). I imagine he could complicate things further, considering he passively supported the mutiny against Jack, and then later protested enough to get himself thrown overboared. I am curious as to how he had expected the mutiny to go.

    Anyway, I eagerly await further updates and hope for a happy, soppy, (as possible without horrible OOCness) romantic ending for all characters involved. Oh, and Henriette is great, the best OC ever.
    Report Review

  • From kspence on June 20, 2007
    Having read your author's notes at the beginning of this story, all I can say is, thank goodness you've taken up your old writing hobby again because what we have here is something that's rarer-than-hens'-teeth in the world of fanfiction: not only is it an impressively well written PoTC story (a REALLY impressively written PoTC story), but all the characters are completely 'in character', it has a proper, engaging plot and everything, you make relevant reference to lots of nautical stuff along the way, and, (my personal favourite this) you're exploring the possible relationship between Jack Sparrow and Hector Barbossa (forget giant octopuses and swirling vortex CGI thingys - that's the most engaging part of the films bar nothing) very convincingly. Oooo, it's got Captain Barbossa in it, and he's not just there to be a foil so someone can be responsible for tying up Will Turner and doing XXX to him and so on. I haven't time to read all of the story just now, but just thought I'd share my giddy first impressions with you - very much looking forward to reading more.
    Report Review

  • From MyraThorne on June 17, 2007
    hey, what can I say? I like this one. Most of all because, even though it's AU, the characters are true to the movie. Whee!

    Myra
    Report Review

  • 1
T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!