Click Here!

  • 1

Reviews for An Offer He Can't Refuse

By : KittyMartin
  • From ANON - Sid on July 09, 2006
    Well I thought it was a really good story, some of these other reviewers just don't appreciate good fics. Just because it's an odd pairing your getting bad reviews and a one star rating, it reallt aint fair at all but what can you do, people are going to be ignorant and stupid so anyway I'm done ranting...

    Right. I liked it a lot actually, I was surprised to find a story about Ragetti, he's my favourite character from POTC so I'm glad you wrote it though.

    Cheers
    Report Review

  • From KittyMartin on July 30, 2004
    hi
    Report Review

  • From ANON - DragonLady on February 21, 2004
    Okay. There is one thing wrong with your story: Norrington is not a rapist. He is not an evil bastard. He is an honorable, good man, good enough to be the hero (who in American fiction is always goodhearted and virtuous). For proof, I submit the following quote from Ted Elliot, one of the writersPotCPotC:

    "*That* was exactly the feeling we wanted the audience to have in regards to Norrington: in a different story, he would have been the hero and the romantic lead."

    Norrington would not rape a prisioner. You portrayal of him was out of character.

    However, your Ragetti/eye jokes were highly amusing. You've got a knack for humor: please expand upon that talent.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Morrighan on February 21, 2004
    Found this an interesting and well-written piece, well thought out for the most part, and yes, slightly disturbing, though it's the characterisation that bothers me more than the subject matter. I mean, Norrington is so repressed that he can't even manage to make a decent marriage proposal, so I imagine it'd take considerable extremity for not only to have such unconventional feelings, but also to act on them rather than suppress them. This, I'm afraid, rather stopped the fic being convincing for me, unfortunately.
    Morrighan
    Thisiew iew brought to you by a member of the NDL.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Bekemono on February 03, 2004
    very Inteing.ing...
    certainly a pair i've never seen before!
    you should check out 'Swag'.com or the Pintel_Ragetti yahoo group!
    weeee!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Cassandra on January 30, 2004
    Odd but well written. Norringtons reaction at the end was unexpected. Why would he put Ragetti to death if he felt something for him? Well I'm done reviewing.
    Report Review

  • 1
T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!